Quick answer

Pick Pi-hole if you want the larger body of community guides and you are comfortable pairing it with a separate resolver for encrypted upstreams. Pick AdGuard Home if you want DoH, DoT and per-client rules inside one binary with a built-in DHCP server. Neither blocks ads served from the same domain as the page.

Contents

At a glance

Class
Homelab

Provenance

  • Nov 16, 2026Published

TL;DR · Pi-hole vs AdGuard Home

  • Want encrypted upstreams without extra moving parts? AdGuard Home. DoH, DoT and DoQ are documented as built in.
  • Want the biggest pile of community guides and blocklists? Pi-hole. It is the default answer for a reason.
  • Need a DHCP server in the same tool? AdGuard Home, as long as the host is not Windows.
  • Care about per-device rules? Both support it. AdGuard Home via a client record, Pi-hole via group management.
  • Neither one blocks first-party ads. Both are DNS filters, not browser extensions, and neither can see inside a page.

These two do the same core job: answer DNS queries for your network and return nothing for the domains on your blocklists. Everything past that is a design choice about which conveniences are built in and which you assemble yourself.

I run a DNS filter for one narrow reason: a single place to stop known tracking and advertising domains before any device on the LAN resolves them. If that is also your reason, the feature differences below decide it quickly, because the blocklist part is genuinely equivalent.

What both of them actually do

Both act as a recursive or forwarding resolver for your LAN. Pi-hole’s resolver is FTL, and the project describes it as a “lightweight but powerful inbuilt DNS / DHCP / TFTP” server (Pi-hole FTL documentation). AdGuard Home is distributed as a self-contained binary that the project documents as a DNS server with filtering built in (AdGuard Home overview).

Both intercept at the domain. That sentence is the limit of the entire category, so it is worth dwelling on for one paragraph.

A DNS filter answers a question about a hostname. It does not parse a page. When an advertisement is served from the same domain as the content you asked for, blocking the domain blocks the content, so neither tool touches it. In-page slots sold by the publisher are invisible to both. Cosmetic filtering and element hiding belong to browser extensions, and neither of these projects is one. If your complaint is banner ads on a news site, a DNS filter will disappoint you no matter which one you choose, and that is not a configuration problem.

Blocklists, formats and management

This is where Pi-hole’s maturity shows, and where the two projects diverge most in daily use.

Pi-hole stores domains in an SQLite database. The project documents a domainlist table where the type field distinguishes exact allowlist, exact denylist, regex allowlist and regex denylist, plus an adlist table for subscribed list URLs which pihole -g processes (Pi-hole domain database). It also documents gravity and antigravity tables that are flushed and rebuilt on each gravity run, which is why a backup has to capture the database rather than a generated file.

The evaluation order is published too: exact allowlist, regex allowlist, exact denylist, subscribed allowlists, subscribed denylists, regex denylist (Pi-hole domain database). That ordering is the answer to about half the “why is this domain still resolving” questions I have seen, and Pi-hole is unusual for writing it down explicitly.

AdGuard Home accepts three syntaxes. Its filtering documentation says: “There are three different approaches to writing hosts blocklists: Adblock-style syntax, /etc/hosts syntax, and Domains-only syntax,” and recommends Adblock-style when you are authoring one (AdGuard filtering syntax). That recommendation matters in practice, because Adblock-style syntax is what most public list maintainers already write in.

Blocklist concernPi-holeAdGuard Home
StorageSQLite databaseConfiguration file and filter URLs
Subscriptionsadlist table, rebuilt by pihole -gFilter URL list, refreshed on a schedule
Rule typesExact and regex, allow and denyAdblock-style, hosts, domains-only
Order of precedencePublished, six tiersException rules, which $important overrides
Per-group listsYes, via group managementYes, via clients

The practical consequence: if you already maintain Adblock-syntax lists, AdGuard Home ingests them directly. On Pi-hole, an Adblock-syntax list is not the native format — its native lists are domains and regexes — so verify a list’s format before subscribing.

Encrypted upstreams are where they diverge

This is the single most consequential difference for a homelab, and it is a packaging difference rather than a capability one.

AdGuard Home supports encryption out of the box. Its documentation states that it “supports all modern DNS encryption protocols out-of-the-box: DNS-over-HTTPS, DNS-over-TLS, DNS-over-QUIC,” and that it supports both client-side and server-side DNSCrypt (AdGuard encryption). That covers both directions: encrypted queries leaving your network and encrypted queries arriving from a device that uses your server directly.

Pi-hole does not ship an encrypted upstream in the resolver. Its own upstream configuration accepts “an array of IP addresses and/or hostnames, optionally with a port (#...)” (Pi-hole configuration file) — an address, not a URL scheme. To get DoH you put something in front of it, and the project publishes guides for doing exactly that: cloudflared for DoH and unbound for local recursion. There is also a page on upstream DNS providers if you would rather change who you forward to than encrypt the path.

Read the cloudflared guide’s own warning before you commit to it. The page carries a notice dated November 2025 stating that the proxy-dns feature the guide relies on is deprecated by Cloudflare, that existing installations continue to work and are supported for twelve months after their release date, and that a cloudflared updated after 2 February 2026 will no longer function as the guide describes. New installations “via this method are not recommended.”

That is not a reason to avoid Pi-hole. It is a reason to plan the encrypted path deliberately rather than pasting a guide from 2021. The unbound route has no such third-party dependency.

Per-client rules and how each identifies a device

Both let you apply different rules to different devices. The models differ enough to matter if you have kids’ devices, a work laptop, or an IoT VLAN.

AdGuard Home treats a client as a record. Its client documentation says the product “offers flexible configuration options for connected devices” and “allows you to apply different rules depending on the client” (AdGuard clients). Identification is the interesting part: the runtime determines which client made a query using hosts files, reverse DNS lookups, the ARP table, WHOIS, and DHCP leases. That means a device with a stable name resolves to the right profile even without a fixed IP, though a fixed IP or a DHCP reservation is still the reliable way to guarantee it.

Pi-hole treats a client as a member of a group. Clients are identified by IP address in the client table of its database, and groups then determine which blocklists apply (Pi-hole group management, Pi-hole domain database). The model is more explicit — you build the group, then populate it — and it makes a “kids” or “IoT” group easy to reason about when you have several devices in each.

The practical difference: AdGuard Home’s per-client model is quicker for one-off exceptions. Pi-hole’s group model scales better when you have six devices that should share one policy. Neither requires you to know anything you cannot see in its interface, and both reward fixed addressing — which is why VLAN planning and DHCP reservations come before filter tuning. If you are segmenting the network at the same time, the VLAN walkthrough and the subnet calculator settle the addressing before the filter gets a say.

DHCP, query logs and the web interface

DHCP. AdGuard Home includes a DHCP server, and its documentation is specific: it “can be used as a DHCP server,” it currently does not support DHCP on Windows, it sets itself as the DNS server for DHCP clients by default, and the default lease time is 24 hours (AdGuard DHCP). Pi-hole also offers DHCP, and documents the Docker-specific considerations separately (Pi-hole Docker DHCP).

If both your router and your Pi already hand out addresses, turn one off. Two DHCP servers on one broadcast domain is the classic way to spend a Saturday.

Query logs. Pi-hole records queries in a database documented separately from the domain database (Pi-hole query database), and its web interface reads from it. AdGuard Home configures its query log in the querylog object of AdGuardHome.yaml, including whether the log is enabled, whether it is written to a file, a retention interval, and a memory size (AdGuard configuration).

That configuration file detail is the one thing to internalise about AdGuard Home: everything lives in AdGuardHome.yaml, and the documentation warns that you can modify the file only while the service is not running, “otherwise, any changes to the file will be lost because the running program will overwrite them.” Edit it with the service stopped, or not at all.

Blocking behaviour. Pi-hole documents its blocking modes explicitly, which is where you choose what a blocked query actually receives — an answer the client can deal with quickly rather than a timeout (Pi-hole blocking modes). If pages feel slow when a blocked domain is on them, that setting is usually the reason.

Running a second instance

Redundancy is the part people skip and then regret, because a DNS filter is a single point of failure for the whole house. When it goes down, nothing resolves, and every complaint in the house is addressed to you.

Neither project ships built-in clustering. The working pattern is the same on both: run a second instance on a second host, keep its configuration identical, and hand both addresses to DHCP as primary and secondary DNS. Clients fall back to the second when the first stops answering, though how quickly depends on the client.

On Pi-hole that means maintaining two databases. Subscribed lists can be re-fetched with pihole -g on each node, but hand-written rules and group assignments have to be copied. On AdGuard Home it means two AdGuardHome.yaml files kept in sync — one file per node, which is easier to diff but easier to forget.

Two warnings from experience, offered as pattern rather than measurement. First, a second instance on the same physical host or the same SD card is not redundancy; it is the same failure with a second IP. Second, if you are virtualising, put the pair on different hosts — the AdGuard Home on Proxmox walkthrough covers the container setup and the second-instance step in detail, and the Proxmox storage backend comparison is the right place to settle where that container’s disk lives.

Which one should you pick

Pick AdGuard Home if you want encrypted DNS without a second daemon, a DHCP server in the same tool, and a configuration you can version-control as a single file. It is the shorter path from “I want DoH” to “DoH is running,” and its per-client model is the more convenient of the two for a handful of devices.

Pick Pi-hole if you want the largest body of existing guides, a large catalogue of published blocklists already written in hosts format, and a documented precedence order that makes debugging predictable. It is the safer answer when you are learning the category, because almost every problem you hit has already been written up.

Run neither alone if the household depends on the network. Add the second instance at build time, not after the first outage.

Do not expect either to replace a browser extension. Third-party ad and tracker domains are what these tools see. First-party advertising, in-page slots, and anything served from the content domain are outside their reach by construction, and no amount of list tuning changes that.

For the storage decision underneath whichever you choose, ZFS vs Btrfs covers the pool your container or VM will sit on, and the reverse proxy comparison covers how you put a certificate and hostname in front of the admin interface so you are not managing it over plain HTTP on port 80.

Frequently asked questions

Is AdGuard Home better than Pi-hole?
Better at different things. AdGuard Home ships encrypted upstream support and a DHCP server in one binary, which Pi-hole requires separate software to match. Pi-hole has the larger install base and a deeper library of community guides. For a plain blocklist and a dashboard, both do the job and the choice mostly comes down to which trade-offs you want to own.
Does Pi-hole support DNS-over-HTTPS?
Not in the resolver itself. Pi-hole’s documented encrypted-upstream route is a separate piece of software in front of it, with the project publishing guides for cloudflared and for unbound, and its upstream configuration taking an address plus an optional port rather than a URL scheme. Its cloudflared guide carries a deprecation warning dated November 2025 about the proxy-dns feature that guide depends on, so read that warning before you build on it.
Can either one block YouTube ads?
No, not reliably, and not for the reason people hope. Both are DNS filters, so they can only block or allow whole domain names. An ad served from the same domain as the video you asked for cannot be separated from that video by a DNS answer. In-page advertising and first-party ad slots are outside what either tool can do, and neither is a browser extension.
Which one is lighter on a Raspberry Pi?
Both run comfortably on a Raspberry Pi, and Pi-hole publishes its requirement as 512 MB of RAM with a minimum of 2 GB of free disk space and 4 GB recommended. AdGuard Home’s own documentation describes a single self-contained binary rather than publishing a memory floor, so I am not going to quote a figure for it. Check your specific board’s memory before you add other services to the same host.
Can I run two instances for redundancy?
Yes, with either tool, and the usual method is the same: run a second instance on a second host with the same configuration and hand both addresses to your DHCP server as primary and secondary DNS. Neither project ships a built-in cluster that keeps two nodes in sync, so the lists and rules you maintain have to be copied across deliberately.
How do I back up Pi-hole or AdGuard Home?
Pi-hole keeps its blocklists, rules and client definitions in an SQLite database under its own directory, and its gravity tables are rebuilt on each gravity run, so a backup has to capture the database rather than a generated list file. AdGuard Home writes everything to AdGuardHome.yaml, which its documentation says you can edit only while the service is stopped, because a running instance overwrites the file. Back up that one file and you have the configuration.
Do I still need an ad blocker in the browser?
If you want in-page ads gone, yes. A DNS filter cannot see inside a page, so cosmetic element blocking and first-party advertising are both out of reach. The two tools overlap with a browser extension on third-party ad domains and nothing else. Running both is normal, not redundant.
Which one has better per-device control?
AdGuard Home exposes per-client configuration as a first-class feature in its own documentation, including applying different rules depending on the client. Pi-hole does this through group management, which assigns clients to groups and applies blocklists per group. Both work; AdGuard Home’s model is a single client record, while Pi-hole’s is a group you build and then populate.

Sources and corrections

Last updated
Methodology
See our methodology for research and review standards. It draws on 19 cited sources, listed below, each checked against the original page on the date above. Feature claims on this page come from the two projects’ own documentation, read on 2026-11-16: docs.pi-hole.net for prerequisites, FTL, the config file, blocking modes, group management, the domain and query databases, the cloudflared and unbound guides, and Docker DHCP; and adguard-dns.io’s knowledge base plus the AdGuardTeam GitHub repository for the overview, configuration file, clients, DHCP, encryption, Raspberry Pi notes and filter syntax. Memory and disk figures are quoted only where a project publishes one. Neither memory usage nor blocklist sizes were measured for this page, so no such figure is quoted.
Corrections
Spotted an error? Email a correction with the affected line and what you found. The draft includes this page’s address. Verified changes are recorded here. Contact details.

About the author

Written by Lowell K. Wood IV, who builds and runs TechFuelHQ from St. Louis, Missouri.