Pick Unraid for mixed-size drives you already own ($49-249 one-time), TrueNAS Community Edition for uniform drives and ZFS integrity on 8GB+ RAM, and openmediavault for low-RAM Debian boxes. Proxmox is a hypervisor, not a NAS OS — by its own documentation it serves no shares; it belongs under a NAS, not instead of one.
Provenance
- Aug 20, 2026Published
- Nov 18, 2026Last substantive update
Jump to a decision
Every NAS thread ends in the same four names, and one of them does not belong.
I spent an evening verifying the current state of all four against their own release notes, pricing pages, and documentation, because so much of the standing advice on this comparison describes products that no longer exist, and the details that changed are exactly the ones that decide the purchase: TrueNAS SCALE is gone as a name, TrueNAS CORE is discontinued as a product, Unraid’s “subscription” is not one, and Proxmox, the name that starts half the arguments, does not serve a single network share out of the box and never claimed it could.
Here is the decision, then the evidence.
Picking the OS is the first decision; picking the disks under it is the second. If you are buying six 20TB-plus drives, the rebuild math decides your layout before the filesystem does.
The short version
Two are free. One is worth paying for. One is a hypervisor wearing a costume.
Mixed drives you already own, apps with minimum friction, money available: Unraid. Uniform drives, integrity as the priority, 8GB of RAM to spare: TrueNAS Community Edition. A weak or small box, Debian comfort, zero budget: openmediavault. And if virtual machines are the actual point of the server, run Proxmox — with a NAS on top of it, not instead of one.
The state of play, November 2026
| Unraid | TrueNAS CE | openmediavault | Proxmox VE | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Version | 7.4.0 (Nov 2026) | 25.10.8 (Nov 2026) | 8.6.1-1 (Nov 2026) | 9.2 (May 2026) |
| Cost | $49 / $109 / $249 once | Free | Free | Free² |
| Storage | mixed-size parity array | ZFS only | mdadm + 16 mountable filesystems | for VM disks, not shares |
| RAM floor¹ | none published | 8GB | 1GiB | 1GB (2GB + guests) |
| Apps | Community Apps (Docker) | TrueNAS Apps (Docker) | omv-extras plugins | VMs + LXC only |
¹ Official documentation figures; Unraid’s getting-started docs publish no RAM number (only a 4GB USB stick requirement) and its forum moderators suggest 4GB as the practical minimum. ² Subscriptions run €120 (repo access only, no tickets) to €1,100 (unlimited tickets) per socket per year; the free package repo is officially labeled not recommended for production.
What the old comparisons get wrong
The rename nobody indexed. TrueNAS SCALE became TrueNAS Community Edition with 25.04 “Fangtooth” in April 2025, and the FreeBSD-based CORE line is formally finished. The software status page says it is no longer under active development, with 13.0-U6.8 and 13.3-U1.2 as the final builds. Any comparison still weighing “CORE vs SCALE” is a museum piece.
Unraid’s pricing produces the loudest arguments and the most misinformation. The licenses are perpetual. The $36 a year on the Starter and Unleashed tiers is optional and only gates new feature releases; your installed version keeps working and keeps receiving security patches within its minor version until that minor version reaches end of life, and Unraid supports the two newest public minor versions. Lime Technology shipped 7.2.8 with a WebGUI CVE fix three weeks after 7.3.2 was already current, and on November 10, 2026 it released the 7.3.5 security update the same day as 7.4.0. Call it a subscription and its forum will correct you, with citations.
RAIDZ expansion stopped being a differentiator. TrueNAS shipped it in 24.10 in October 2024, sponsored by iXsystems, and Unraid’s ZFS pools gained the same one-drive-at-a-time growth in 7.2.0 a year later. The classic “ZFS can’t grow one disk at a time” objection is out of date on both.
openmediavault deserves both its reputation and its asterisk. It is the lightest real NAS OS here, it is genuinely free, and the third-party omv-extras mergerfs and SnapRAID plugins recreate Unraid’s mixed-drive economics without the license fee.
The asterisk is structural: on November 18, 2026, GitHub’s contributor list for the core repository showed 8,442 commits from the lead developer against 26 from the next contributor, so most of the core rests on one maintainer. OMV 7 also went end-of-life in June 2026, so a fresh install today should start at OMV 8.
The category error
Proxmox VE describes itself as a server management platform for enterprise virtualization. Its storage documentation lists NFS and SMB only as backends it mounts from somewhere else, to hold VM disks and backups. There is no interface anywhere in it for creating a share, and its community answers the recurring question without hedging: “not a NAS software like TrueNAS,” in its own words. That settles it.
So why is it in every NAS thread? Because homelabbers correctly run it as the base layer and put the NAS on top — a TrueNAS or OMV virtual machine with disks passed through, a fileserver LXC, or bare Samba on the underlying Debian. All of those work.
None of them makes Proxmox a NAS OS; they make it a hypervisor hosting one, which is a different decision with different failure modes. If that is your situation, the real question is which storage backend to run under Proxmox, and we compare exactly that separately.
Picking by your actual constraint
Your drives are a mixed bag. Unraid’s parity array takes different sizes in one protected pool, and openmediavault reaches the same shape via the third-party omv-extras mergerfs and SnapRAID plugins. TrueNAS will let you mix sizes but charges you for it: ZFS caps every disk in a vdev at the smallest member’s capacity.
Your RAM is tight. TrueNAS officially wants 8GB plus 1GB per drive past eight. OMV officially runs in 1GiB. On a repurposed thin client or an N100 with soldered memory, that spread decides the argument by itself.
You want apps without ceremony. Unraid’s Community Apps store is, in my judgment, the smoothest catalog in home NAS. TrueNAS moved its apps backend from Kubernetes to plain Docker in 24.10, which simplified life, though its forums carry real migration scars from that transition, and the forum threads from the 25.04 virtualization overhaul read the same way. OMV needs the omv-extras compose plugin before Docker exists at all.
Your data is the point and nothing else is. TrueNAS. It is not close, because the whole platform is organized around one job: ZFS end-to-end with checksumming, snapshots, and replication, maintained by a company whose paying enterprise customers keep the storage layer honest whether or not the home users complain loudly enough. For how ZFS compares with Btrfs on a home NAS, see ZFS vs Btrfs.
Budget rules everything. OMV and TrueNAS are free. Unraid’s $49 Starter covers six attached devices, which fits most first builds; count your drives before assuming the $109 tier. Run your drive plan through the RAID capacity calculator first — parity overhead changes the real cost per usable terabyte more than the license does.
Whatever wins, put it on hardware that idles politely. A NAS runs 24/7, so the idle-power economics compound annually, and the budget NAS builds and old-PC conversion guide both start from that premise. For the disks, see best NAS hard drives.
You’d rather buy a NAS than build one. Then the choice is the vendor’s OS, not these four: NAS software at month eight covers DSM, UGOS Pro, TOS and QTS, and Synology or build runs the five-year cost of each route.
Which NAS software fits Plex?
Unraid’s Community Applications catalog installs community-maintained Plex containers from the Apps tab, though Unraid says it does not directly support those community apps. TrueNAS Community Edition has a guided Plex app with an explicit GPU selection in Resources. openmediavault recommends containerized software to avoid package conflicts, and Proxmox runs Plex in a guest or container you configure yourself.
Hardware transcoding can reverse the easy-install ranking. Plex requires compatible hardware, device access and an active Plex Pass for hardware-accelerated streaming, and Docker needs the relevant device passed into the container. After setup, force a conversion and confirm (hw) in the Plex Dashboard. Which NAS boxes actually hardware-transcode is in the best NAS for Plex and Jellyfin.
Windows or Ubuntu instead of a NAS OS?
Windows 11 and Windows Server can host SMB shares, and Canonical’s Ubuntu guide builds a Samba file server by hand: install Samba, define a share in /etc/samba/smb.conf, set permissions and restart the services. Either serves the same clients, but neither gives you Unraid’s mixed-drive parity, TrueNAS’s ZFS management or OMV’s NAS dashboard, so plan storage protection and backups yourself. Proxmox VE’s host requirements specify 64-bit Debian, so macOS isn’t a Proxmox host option; a Mac can still manage a Proxmox server through its web interface.
Method and limits
Versions, prices and RAM figures were re-checked on November 18, 2026 against the vendors’ release notes, pricing pages and documentation, with community claims labeled as community claims; the source list below carries the URLs.
What this page is not: a hands-on bench of the four installers side by side. I have not run these four concurrently on matched hardware, so you will find no throughput or power numbers here — when we measure that, it will publish as a dataset with the raw files, like our other measured work.
Versions move fast in this space; if the table above and a vendor page ever disagree, the vendor page has moved and this page’s update date tells you by how much.
More storage guides: the storage hub · storage under Proxmox · RAID capacity calculator
Frequently asked questions
Unraid vs TrueNAS vs Proxmox — which should I use for a NAS?
Is TrueNAS SCALE still free, and what happened to CORE?
Is Unraid a subscription now?
Can Proxmox be used as a NAS?
What is the best free TrueNAS alternative in 2026?
How much RAM does each NAS OS need?
Sources and corrections
- Last updated
- Methodology
- See our methodology for research and review standards. It draws on 29 cited sources, listed below, each checked against the original page on the date shown beside it.
- Sources
- Unraid pricing (Starter/Unleashed/Lifetime) accessed 2026-11-18
- Unraid licensing FAQ (perpetual licenses, $36/yr extension, patch policy) accessed 2026-11-18
- Unraid 7.2.0 release notes (ZFS RAIDZ expansion, added filesystems) accessed 2026-08-20
- Unraid 7.4.0 release notes (November 10, 2026) accessed 2026-11-18
- Unraid 7.3.5 release notes (November 10, 2026 security update) accessed 2026-11-18
- Unraid 7.2.8 release notes (CVE-2026-3838 patch after 7.3.2) accessed 2026-11-18
- TrueNAS software status (25.10.8 current; CORE no longer under active development) accessed 2026-11-18
- TrueNAS Community Edition 25.04 announcement (SCALE renamed CE) accessed 2026-08-20
- TrueNAS 24.10 release notes (RAIDZ expansion; apps move to Docker) accessed 2026-08-20
- TrueNAS 25.10 hardware guide (8GB RAM, +1GB per drive past eight) accessed 2026-11-18
- openmediavault release table (OMV 8 Synchrony; OMV 7 EOL Jun 2026) accessed 2026-11-18
- openmediavault prerequisites (1GiB RAM minimum) accessed 2026-11-18
- openmediavault stable package index (synchrony dist; current openmediavault version) accessed 2026-11-18
- omv-extras plugin wiki (mergerfs, SnapRAID, compose) accessed 2026-08-20
- openmediavault contributor data (GitHub API) accessed 2026-11-18
- Proxmox VE system requirements accessed 2026-11-18
- Proxmox VE storage documentation (NFS/CIFS as client backends) accessed 2026-08-20
- Proxmox VE subscription pricing accessed 2026-11-18
- Proxmox VE package repositories (no-subscription repo guidance) accessed 2026-08-20
- Proxmox VE roadmap (9.2 release) accessed 2026-11-18
- Microsoft SMB file sharing overview accessed 2026-10-11
- Ubuntu Server: set up Samba as a file server accessed 2026-10-11
- Proxmox VE graphical user interface accessed 2026-10-11
- Unraid Community Applications documentation accessed 2026-10-11
- TrueNAS Plex deployment documentation accessed 2026-10-11
- Plex hardware-accelerated streaming requirements accessed 2026-10-11
- openmediavault 8 documentation, plugins and container guidance accessed 2026-10-11
- Unraid forums: practical RAM guidance for 7.x (community) accessed 2026-08-20
- Proxmox forum: ZFS file share thread (community; not-a-NAS answer) accessed 2026-08-20
- Update log
- 2026-11-18 — Updated the version table to Unraid 7.4.0, TrueNAS 25.10.8 and openmediavault 8.6.1-1, clarified when unextended Unraid licenses stop getting patches, and shortened the Plex and Windows sections.
- 2026-10-11 — Added how Windows and Ubuntu file servers differ from dedicated NAS systems and Proxmox, and a Plex section on each platform’s install route and hardware transcoding.
- 2026-08-22 — The openmediavault version cell read 8.5.7; the project’s own stable package index (synchrony dist, Release file dated Fri, 21 Aug 2026 13:47:32 UTC) serves openmediavault_8.5.6-1_all.deb, so the cell now reads 8.5.6-1 and the package index joins the source list. I re-checked everything else in the table live, and it is unchanged: Unraid 7.3.2 dated 2026-07-08 with 7.4.0 still a beta (7.4.0-beta.1, 2026-08-14); TrueNAS 25.10.6 dated 12 August 2026; Proxmox VE 9.2 ‘Released 21. May 2026’. I re-read the 7.2.8 story at source: 7.2.8 is dated 2026-07-29, three weeks after 7.3.2, and its notes say ‘Fixed a WebGUI update.php path-traversal command execution vulnerability, CVE-2026-3838’.
- 2026-08-20 — First published, with versions, prices and documentation quotes checked against vendor sources and community claims labeled in-line.
- Corrections
- Spotted an error? Email a correction with the affected line and what you found. The draft includes this page’s address. Verified changes are recorded here. Contact details.